What is a threat?
A threat is any communication indicating an intention to do harm. It can be communicated directly or indirectly either by words (whether written or spoken) or by conduct, or a combination of both [Criminal Law Consolidation Act (SA) s 19(3)]. For example, driving a motor vehicle at high speed on the wrong side of the road and stopping just short of another car can constitute a threat [see South Australian Police v Bednarz (SASC, 17 February 1995, Jud No S4959, unreported)].
In determining whether words or actions constitute a threat there is a difference between an intention to cause harm, and someone who is merely “sounding off” who does not intend to create any fear. For example a statement 'I feel like I could kill my spouse' could be interpreted as an expression of emotions, whereas 'I want to kill my spouse' is a threat to do harm.
The threat does not need to be directed at the person who heard it (see for example Carter v R (1994) 176 LSJS 112).
Threaten death
It is an offence if a person, without lawful excuse:
- threatens to kill or endanger the life of another; and
- intends to create a fear that the threat will be carried out, or is recklessly indifferent to whether such a fear was created.
Maximum penalty:
- Basic offence: 10 years imprisonment
- Aggravated offence: 12 years imprisonment
Examples of aggravated offences include where the victim is a child or a spouse of the defendant, or where the offence was committed intending to prevent the victim from taking legal proceedings.
[s 19(1) Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA)]
Threaten Harm
It is an offence where a person, without lawful excuse:
- threatens to cause harm to another;
- intending to create a fear that the threat will be carried out, or is recklessly indifferent to whether such a fear was created.
Maximum penalty:
- Basic offence: 5 years imprisonment.
- Aggravated offence: 7 years imprisonment
- Aggravated offence where the victim is a police officer, prison officer, employee in a training centre or other law enforcement officer: eight years imprisonment
- Aggravated offence where the victim is engaged in a prescribed occupation or employment (whether on a paid or volunteer basis), such as hospital, retail and emergency services workers, and the offender knows this when assaulting them: eight years imprisonment [Criminal Law Consolidation (General) Regulations 2021 (SA) reg 4]
[Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) s 19(2)]
Threats to damage property
It is also an offence to make threats against the property of a person.
Maximum penalty:
- Basic offence: 5 years imprisonment.
- Aggravated offence: 7 years imprisonment.
- Aggravated offence by threat to commit arson: 15 years imprisonment.
[Criminal Law Consolidation Act s 85(4)].
See also: Arson and property damage.
Unlawful Threats : Last Revised: Fri Aug 26th 2022
The content of the Law
Handbook is made available as
a public service
for information purposes only
and should not be relied upon
as a substitute for legal
advice. See
Disclaimer for
details. For free and
confidential legal advice
in South Australia call 1300
366 424.